713-224-5529

Will Texas Eliminate Forensic Hypnosis?


Eliminate Forensic Hypnosis

The 86th legislative session in Texas has welcomed many new bills. One of the most controversial is the prohibition of forensic hypnosis from a criminal courtroom proposed by State Senator Juan “Chuy” Hinojosa. You may have seen examples of forensic hypnosis in television dramas such as C.S.I or The Long Island Medium. This practice may be popular for T.V. rankings, but in the criminal justice system forensic hypnosis can lead to false convictions.

Texas has one of the most developed forensic hypnosis programs in the country. The Forensic Investigator Certification Program allows police officers and consultants to “access” the lost memories of witnesses. Devotees of forensic hypnosis will claim the practice is a “relaxation tool,” which allows witnesses and victims to recall what they’ve seen.


Cases of Forensic Hypnosis

There have been a few cases where forensic hypnosis was successful. For example, Lawrence Singleton was discovered by forensic hypnosis for the crime of raping and mutilating a 15-year-old girl named Mary Vincent. However, there is no scientific basis behind forensic hypnosis. While there have been some successes, the majority of forensic hypnosis attempts lead to false accusations.

Clarence Moore is an example of forensic hypnosis gone wrong. The New Jersey man spent 15 years in prison for a rape he never committed because of forensic hypnosis. There was no forensic evidence in his case with the exception of hypnosis. The victim was unable to see her attacker’s face clearly until she “accessed” her memories through forensic hypnosis.

Recently, the third circuit U.S. Court of Appeals in Philadelphia dismissed Moore’s conviction. After over a decade of incarceration, Moore was finally released. He had lost his business, his marriage and was unable to see his children grow up because forensic hypnosis was still considered admissible in court.


Texas and Forensic Hypnosis

Two death row inmates in Texas are fighting back against forensic hypnosis. One of them is Kosoul Chanthakoummane who was convicted of brutally stabbing realtor Sarah Walker to death. He was found guilty because of a sketch released from a hypnotized witness. The other death row inmate is Charles Don Flores, who was convicted of killing Elizabeth “Betty” Black. He was also found guilty because a hypnotized witness recognized him running from the scene.

Both men have been sentenced to death but have been able to delay their execution dates. Their defense has argued for new trials because forensic hypnosis is considered to be “junk science,” and they’re not wrong.

Forensic hypnosis has never been verified in a scientific setting. The debate regarding “repressed memories” has never been fully validated but has been upheld by devoted believers. The program itself is rather informal and quick. It only takes 32 hours to become an investigator, and 40 hours to become a certified forensic investigator. The inconsistency of the forensic hypnosis field has led to half of the U.S. adopting “per se inadmissibility rules,” which bars anyone from using forensic hypnosis as admissible evidence.


Legislation in Texas to Stop Forensic Hypnosis

The bill proposed by Senator Juan “Chuy” Hinojosa would eliminate forensic hypnosis from the court. Any testimony obtained by hypnosis would be considered inadmissible. This would be good news for inmates wrongly accused by hypnosis such as Chanthakoummane and Flores.

Senator Hinojosa’s bill was introduced on February 2nd, so only time will tell. If it passes, the new standard could release many people who were wrongly convicted due to forensic hypnosis. It would also deter law enforcement agencies from relying on forensic hypnosis “experts” when they’re stuck on a case. Not only this, but it would stop funneling resources into a practice which has for so long been considered to be “junk science.”


This blog was last updated on March 12th, 2019.

Client Testimonials

  • 5 Stars
    "Tyler and his team are top notch—with years of experience under their belts they know what strategy will work to advocate for the best possible outcome. They are knowledgeable, professional, and courteous. Like a doctor, you never know you hire a bad attorney until it’s too late, and don’t take a gamble and retain someone else, especially when the clock starts running quickly, once you are arrested for a DWI. Run, don’t walk, to retain Flood and Associates!"
    - Alyssa S
  • 5 Stars
    "So. I can't say enough about Tyler Flood and Associates! BRAVO!! I had a 3rd DWI and my daughter Googled Tyler & Co. Who are DWI SPECIALISTS! I set up an appointment, and was impressed with their knowledge on the Laws and Science of DWI cases! Hank👍💥💥💥💥💥👌"
    - Hank Baerga
  • 5 Stars
    "Tyler Flood did an excellent job in taking care of my situation when no other attorney could do so. He kept communication open by way of text messages and phone calls, I was inform in every step along the way and he represented me well in court. His assistant Andrea was very quick in responding to my emails, I felt comforted by their genuine concerns of my case. Highly recommended"
    - Tamra Elwell
  • 5 Stars
    "Tyler Flood and associates are an astronomical team. Tyler was aggressive when needed to be and very professional during my trail. He left no stone unturned. I highly reccomend Mr. Flood if you ever find yourself in a situation such as myself. The not guilty verdict for a dwi was the best! "
    - Magaly
  • 5 Stars
    "Great experience under terrible circumstances...when your future is at risk, the attorney you chose could decide your fate..Flood & associates took my case personal...I felt I was represented by family...highly recommend Tyler to everyone!"
    - Brent
  • 5 Stars
    "I personally want everyone to know, this is the best law firm for dui issues! They are professional and responds all the time, communications between the office and myself was on par at all times and bottom line. MY CASE WAS DISMISSED!!!"
    - TW David C.
  • 5 Stars
    "Tyler did a great job for me. I never felt like he wanted me to settle. In fact he would encourage me to hang in there and go to trial. In the end my DWI was dismissed the day of trial. I would definitely recommend them."
    - Robin
Read More Testimonials
  • National Association of Criminal Defense Lawyers
  • Texas Criminal Lawyers Association
  • Harris County Criminal Lawyers Association
  • DUI Defense Lawyers Association
  • The American Chemical Society
  • National College for DUI Defense
  • Best DUI Lawyer
  • National Association of Criminal Defense Lawyers
  • Texas Criminal Lawyers Association
  • Harris County Criminal Lawyers Association
  • DUI Defense Lawyers Association
  • The American Chemical Society
  • National College for DUI Defense
Win an xbox Series X
Tyler Flood & Associates